from Coalwire’s Bob Burton. Published by Global Energy Monitor
Study finds dramatic health improvement after closure of US coke plant: A study by New York University researchers published in Environmental Health Research found a 42 per cent reduction in emergency department visits for cardiovascular diseases immediately after the January 2016 closure of the Shenango Coke Works plant in Pittsburgh. The study found that sulphur dioxide emissions fell by 90 per cent near the plant that processed coal into coke for use in steel plants and by 50 per cent at another air-monitoring station about 10 kilometres away. Arsenic emissions fell by 66 per cent after the closure of the 54-year-old coke works owned by DTE Energy closed. George Thurston, one of the study researchers, said the dramatic reduction in hospital presentations after the closure of the coke plant was similar to what has been observed when people quit smoking.
Closure of Pittsburgh Coal-Processing Plant Tied to Local Health Gains
Commentary from NYU Langone Health by George D. Thurston, ScD
The closure in January 2016 of one of Pittsburgh’s biggest coal-processing plants led to immediate and lasting declines in emissions of fossil fuel–related air pollutants. These in turn were linked to near-instant decreases in local heart-related emergency department visits and hospitalizations for cardiovascular diseases, a new study shows. The impact of the closure persisted through at least December 2018, the last month for which data were analyzed.
Led by researchers at NYU Grossman School of Medicine, the study was designed to assess the short- and longer-term health effects of the shutdown of the Shenango Coke Works facility, which for more than 50 years produced coke, a coal-derived product needed for steelmaking. Before closing under community pressure, the plant had incurred millions of dollars in government fines for air and water pollution.
Although the study, performed in a real-life situation, did not demonstrate a cause-and-effect link between any individual’s health and the plant closure, the results of the “natural experiment” showed a strong overall statistical association between the closure and measures of improved health, such as reduced visits to the emergency department, the researchers say.
Published online July 31 in the journal Environmental Research: Health, the study showed that average daily levels of sulfur dioxide, a major toxic chemical component in air pollution and by-product of coke making, fell by 90 percent at government air-monitoring stations near the plant and by 50 percent at another air-monitoring station roughly 10 kilometers (more than 6 miles) away. Arsenic in particulate matter, another coal-combustion by-product that can be inhaled, fell by 66 percent.
Analyses of state health records showed that average weekly visits to the local emergency departments for heart-related problems decreased by 42 percent immediately after the shutdown.
Similar downward trends were observed locally over the long term, with 33 fewer average yearly hospitalizations for heart disease from 2016 through 2018 compared to the three years preceding the plant closure. This included 13 fewer average yearly hospitalizations for ischemic heart disease (typically heart attack) and 12 fewer average yearly hospitalizations for cerebrovascular events (most often stroke).
By contrast, study findings showed no corresponding postclosure drop in trauma-related injuries as reported in visits to the emergency department, an indicator that the cardiovascular health gains were not due to some overall drop in population or in accidents needing emergency care.
In addition, the researchers looked for and found no parallel decreases in air pollution, emergency department visits, or hospitalizations in communities near a still-operating coke plant in Clairton, Pennsylvania, or in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, a town 120 kilometers (75 miles) east of Pittsburgh that has no comparable air-polluting manufacturing operations. The researchers say air quality and health insurance data from these regions acted as “research controls,” allowing them to compare what happened after Shenango closed to what happened elsewhere in the state.
“Our research provides compelling scientific evidence that the closure of this coal-processing coke plant significantly eliminated fossil fuel–related air pollution emissions that improved the air quality and cardiovascular health of nearby residents,” said study lead investigator Wuyue Yu, a doctoral science student at NYU Langone Health.
Numerous past studies have tied air pollutants—including those related to fossil fuel—to immediate upticks in asthma attacks and long-term increases in inflammatory conditions that lead to heart attack and stroke, added Yu.
“The immediate and long-term benefits from dramatic reductions in exposure to air pollution are also analogous to the steady reductions in illness and disease that have been observed over time following smoking cessation,” said senior study investigator George D. Thurston, ScD.
“Our analysis adds to the growing body of scientific evidence that policies implemented to regulate and reduce fossil fuel–related air pollution have real public health benefit,” said Dr. Thurston, a professor in the Departments of Medicine and Population Health at NYU Langone.
For the study, which was funded by the Heinz Endowments, researchers used data provided to the Pennsylvania Department of Health from hospital electronic health records. Researchers restricted their analysis to patients from zip codes immediately surrounding the Shenango and Clairton plants, as well as a government air-monitoring station in Johnstown.
The researchers caution that while the Clairton plant and Johnstown township closely mimic still-polluting and nonpolluting comparisons to the closed Shenango plant, they do not serve as perfect research controls. Other potentially confounding factors not included in the study, such as local improvements in lifestyle from diet or exercise, might explain some of the differences observed in the study.
Still, they say their study serves as another scientific milestone about the health benefits of cleaner air. It also provides a public policy reminder about the need to carefully monitor air quality after closing polluting plants and to assess their health impact on nearby residents.
They also say their research could act as an effective guide to monitoring the health changes flowing from the closure of other fossil fuel–powered plants and to using more natural experiments in public health research.
Original article: An interrupted time series analysis of the cardiovascular health benefits of a coal coking operation closure
Wuyue Yu2,1 and George D Thurston1
Published 31 July 2023 • © 2023 The Author(s). Published by IOP Publishing Ltd
, , Citation Wuyue Yu and George D Thurston 2023 Environ. Res.: Health 1 045002DOI 10.1088/2752-5309/ace4ea
With the widespread implementation of air pollution mitigation strategies for health and climate policy, there is an emerging interest in accountability studies to validate whether a reduction of air pollution exposure, in fact, produces the human health benefits estimated from past air pollution epidemiology. The closure of a coal coking plant provides an ideal ‘natural’ experiment opportunity to rigorously evaluate the health benefits of air pollution emissions reductions. In this study, we applied an interrupted time series model to test the hypothesis that the substantial reduction in air pollution induced by the closure of the Shenango, Inc. coke plant in Pittsburgh, PA during January, 2016 was followed by immediate and/or longer-term cumulative local cardiovascular health benefits. We observed a 90% decrease in nearby SO2 levels, as well as significant reductions in coal-related fine particulate matter constituents (sulfate and arsenic), after the closure. Statistically significant cardiovascular health benefits were documented in the local population, including a 42% immediate drop (95% CI: 33%, 51%) in cardiovascular emergency department (ED) visits from the pre-closure mean. A longer-term downward trend was also observed for overall emergency visits at −0.14 (95% CI: −0.17, −0.11) visits per week rate of decrease after the closure, vs. a rise of 0.17 (95% CI: 0.14, 0.20) visits per week before. Similarly, inpatient cardiovascular hospitalizations per year showed a decrease after closure (−27.97 [95% CI: −46.90, −9.04], as compared with a 5.09 [95% CI: −13.84, 24.02] average increase in cases/year over the prior three years). Our study provides clear evidence that this intervention lowering fossil fuel-associated air pollution benefited public health in both the short and longer term, while also providing validation of the past use of observational air pollution epidemiology effect estimates in policy analyses.
- Alexeeff S E, Liao N S, Liu X, Eeden S K V D and Sidney S 2021 Long-term PM2.5 exposure and risks of ischemic heart disease and stroke events: review and meta-analysis J. Am. Heart Assoc. 10 e016890
- Allegheny County Health Department Air Quality Program 2019 Proposed revision to the allegheny county portion of the Pennsylvania state implementation plan (Allegheny County Health Department Air Quality Program) (available at: www.alleghenycounty.us/uploadedFiles/Allegheny_Home/Health_Department/Programs/Air_Quality/SIPs/90-SIP-PM25-ATTAIN-2012-NAAQS-09-12-2019.pdf)
- American Lung Association 2022 “State of the Air” 2022 American Lung Association
- Aylin P, Bottle A, Wakefield J, Jarup L and Elliott P 2001 Proximity to coke works and hospital admissions for respiratory and cardiovascular disease in England and Wales Thorax 56 228
- Bell M L, Morgenstern R D and Harrington W 2011 Quantifying the human health benefits of air pollution policies: review of recent studies and new directions in accountability research Environ. Sci. Policy 14 357–68
- Bernal J L, Cummins S and Gasparrini A 2017 Interrupted time series regression for the evaluation of public health interventions: a tutorial Int. J. Epidemiol. 46 348–55
- Bernal J L, Soumerai S and Gasparrini A 2018 A methodological framework for model selection in interrupted time series studies J. Clin. Epidemiol. 103 82–91
- Bhaskaran K, Gasparrini A, Hajat S, Smeeth L and Armstrong B 2013 Time series regression studies in environmental epidemiology Int. J. Epidemiol. 42 1187–95
- Bhopal R S, Phillimore P, Moffatt S and Foy C 1994 Is living near a coking works harmful to health? A study of industrial air pollution J. Epidemiol. Community Health48 237
- Boing A F, Desouza P, Boing A C, Kim R and Subramanian S V 2022 Air pollution, socioeconomic status, and age-specific mortality risk in the United States JAMA Netw. Open 5 e2213540
- Boogaard H, Van Erp A M, Walker K D and Shaikh R 2017 Accountability studies on air pollution and health: the HEI experience Curr. Environ. Health Rep. 4 514–22
- Brink L L, Marshall L P, Hacker K A and Talbott E O 2019 Changes in emergency department visits for respiratory and cardiovascular disease after closure of a coking operation near Pittsburgh, PA J. Air Pollut. Health 23 234–52
- Burns J, Boogaard H, Polus S, Pfadenhauer L M, Rohwer A C, Van Erp A M, Turley R and Rehfuess E 2019 Interventions to reduce ambient particulate matter air pollution and their effect on health Cochrane Database Syst. Rev.
- Cao S, Duan X, Zhao X, Ma J, Dong T, Huang N, Sun C, He B and Wei F 2014 Health risks from the exposure of children to As, Se, Pb and other heavy metals near the largest coking plant in China Sci. Total Environ. 472 1001–9
- Díaz-Somoano M, López-Antón M A, Suárez-Ruiz I, Calvo M, Suárez S, García R and Martínez-Tarazona M R 2012 Impact of a semi-industrial coke processing plant in the surrounding surface soil: part I: trace element content Fuel Process. Technol. 10235–45
- Fedak K M, Bernal A, Capshaw Z A and Gross S 2015 Applying the Bradford Hill criteria in the 21st century: how data integration has changed causal inference in molecular epidemiology Emerg. Themes Epidemiol. 12 14
- Ghose M K, Majee S R and Sinha P K 1999 Monitoring and assessment of impact on air environment caused by coke plant operations in India Int. J. Environ. Stud. 56475–82
- Gratziou C 2009 Respiratory, cardiovascular and other physiological consequences of smoking cessation Curr. Med. Res. Opin. 25 535–45
- Gwynn R C and Thurston G D 2001 The burden of air pollution: impacts among racial minorities Environ. Health Perspect. 109 501–6
- Hajat A, Hsia C and O’neill M S 2015 Socioeconomic disparities and air pollution exposure: a global review Curr. Environ. Health Rep. 2 440–50
- Henneman L R F, Choirat C and Zigler A C M 2019 Accountability assessment of health improvements in the United States associated with reduced coal emissions between 2005 and 2012 Epidemiology 30 477–85
- Henneman L R F, Liu C, Mulholland J A and Russell A G 2017 Evaluating the effectiveness of air quality regulations: a review of accountability studies and frameworks J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc. 67 144–72
- Hill A B 1965 The environment and disease: association or causation? Proc. R. Soc. Med. 58 295–300
- Hu Y, Chen B, Yin Z, Jia L, Zhou Y and Jin T 2006 Increased risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases in coke oven workers: interaction between occupational exposure and smoking Thorax 61 290–5
- Huet-Vaughn E, Muller N and Hsu Y-C 2018 Livestreaming pollution: a new form of public disclosure and a catalyst for citizen engagement? National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series 24664
- Jbaily A, Zhou X, Liu J, Lee T-H, Kamareddine L, Verguet S and Dominici F 2022 Air pollution exposure disparities across US population and income groups Nature 601228–33
- Kelly M and Fischman G 2014 Allegheny County Health Department Air Quality Program Point Source Emission Inventory Report 2014 Allegheny County Health Department
- Khare P and Baruah B P 2011 Estimation of emissions of SO2, PM2.5, and metals released from coke ovens using high sulfur coals Environ. Prog Sustain. Energy 30123–9
- Lange C L, Smith V A and Kahler D M 2022 Pittsburgh air pollution changes during the COVID-19 lockdown Environ. Adv. 7 100149
- Maciejczyk P, Chen L-C and Thurston G 2021 The role of fossil fuel combustion metals in PM2.5 air pollution health associations Atmosphere 12 1086
- Martenies S E, Akherati A, Jathar S and Magzamen S 2019 Health and environmental justice implications of retiring two coal-fired power plants in the southern front range region of Colorado GeoHealth 3 266–83
- Marusic K 2018 ER visits for asthma dropped 38% the year after one of Pittsburgh’s biggest polluters shut down Environmental Health News (available at: www.ehn.org/shenango-coke-works-closed-asthma-dropped-2566777141.html)(Accessed 29 December 2022)
- Mckeon T P, Anil V, Penning T M and Hwang W-T 2022 Air pollution and lung cancer survival in Pennsylvania Lung Cancer 170 65–73
- Mu L, Peng L, Cao J, He Q, Li F, Zhang J, Liu X and Bai H 2013 Emissions of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons from coking industries in China Particuology 1186–93
- Mu L, Peng L, Liu X, Bai H, Song C, Wang Y and Li Z 2012 Emission characteristics of heavy metals and their behavior during coking processes Environ. Sci. Technol. 466425–30
- Parodi S, Stagnaro E, Casella C, Puppo A, Daminelli E, Fontana V, Valerio F and Vercelli M 2005 Lung cancer in an urban area in Northern Italy near a coke oven plant Lung Cancer 47 155–64
- Parodi S, Vercelli M, Stella A, Stagnaro E and Valerio F 2003 Lymphohaematopoietic system cancer incidence in an urban area near a coke oven plant: an ecological investigation Occup. Environ. Med. 60 187
- Polosa R, Morjaria J B, Prosperini U, Russo C, Pennisi A, Puleo R, Caruso M and Caponnetto P 2018 Health effects in COPD smokers who switch to electronic cigarettes: a retrospective-prospective 3-year follow-up Int. J. Chron. Obstruct. Pulmon. Dis. 13 2533–42
- Porter T R, Kent S T, Su W, Beck H M and Gohlke J M 2014 Spatiotemporal association between birth outcomes and coke production and steel making facilities in Alabama, USA: a cross-sectional study Environ. Health 13 85
- Qiu C, Peng B, Cheng S, Xia Y and Tu B 2013 The effect of occupational exposure to benzo[a]pyrene on neurobehavioral function in coke oven workers Am. J. Ind. Med.56 347–55
- R Core Team 2022 R: a language and environment for statistical computing (available at: www.R-project.org/)
- Rauner S, Bauer N, Dirnaichner A, Dingenen R V, Mutel C and Luderer G 2020 Coal-exit health and environmental damage reductions outweigh economic impacts Nat. Clim. Change 10 308–12
- Rich D Q 2017 Accountability studies of air pollution and health effects: lessons learned and recommendations for future natural experiment opportunities Environ. Int. 100 62–78
- Saikia J, Saikia P, Boruah R and Saikia B K 2015 Ambient air quality and emission characteristics in and around a non-recovery type coke oven using high sulphur coal Sci. Total Environ. 530–531 304–13
- Schraufnagel D E et al 2019a Air pollution and noncommunicable diseases: a review by the forum of international respiratory societies’ environmental committee, part 1: the damaging effects of air pollution Chest 155 409–16
- Schraufnagel D E, Balmes J R, De Matteis S, Hoffman B, Kim W J, Perez-Padilla R, Rice M, Sood A, Vanker A and Wuebbles D J 2019b Health benefits of air pollution reduction Ann. Am. Thorac. Soc. 16 1478–87
- Thurston G D, Ito K and Lall R 2011 A source apportionment of U.S. fine particulate matter air pollution Atmos. Environ. 45 3924–36
- Turner S L, Karahalios A, Forbes A B, Taljaard M, Grimshaw J M, Cheng A C, Bero L and Mckenzie J E 2020 Design characteristics and statistical methods used in interrupted time series studies evaluating public health interventions: a review J. Clin. Epidemiol. 122 1–11
- National Toxicology Program 2016 14th Report on carcinogens U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Vohra K, Vodonos A, Schwartz J, Marais E A, Sulprizio M P and Mickley L J 2021 Global mortality from outdoor fine particle pollution generated by fossil fuel combustion: results from GEOS-Chem Environ. Res. 195 110754
- Wang S et al 2016 Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons exposure and lung function decline among coke-oven workers: a four-year follow-up study Environ. Res. 150 14–22
- Weitkamp E A, Lipsky E M, Pancras P J, Ondov J M, Polidori A, Turpin B J and Robinson A L 2005 Fine particle emission profile for a large coke production facility based on highly time-resolved fence line measurements Atmos. Environ. 39 6719–33
- Yang K, Jiang X, Cheng S, Chen C, Cao X and Tu B 2017 Effects of coke oven emissions and benzo[a]pyrene on blood pressure and electrocardiogram in coke oven workers J. Occup. Health 59 1–7
- Yang Y, Ruan Z, Wang X, Yang Y, Mason T G, Lin H and Tian L 2019 Short-term and long-term exposures to fine particulate matter constituents and health: a systematic review and meta-analysis Environ. Pollut. 247 874–82
- Yinon L and Thurston G 2017 An evaluation of the health benefits achieved at the time of an air quality intervention in three Israeli cities Environ. Int. 102 66–73
- Zajusz-Zubek E, Radko T and Mainka A 2017 Fractionation of trace elements and human health risk of submicron particulate matter (PM1) collected in the surroundings of coking plants Environ. Monit. Assess. 189 389