DAILY SCIENCE in Anthropocene magazine
First continental scale study weighs floating solar panels against new dam construction
Floating solar panels on existing hydropower reservoirs could, in the best-case scenario, make it unnecessary to construct any of the new hydropower dams currently planned in Africa, according to a new analysis. The study is among the first to analyze the potential for floating solar panels (or FPV, short for floating photovoltaics) at a continental scale.
Population growth and economic development are predicted to triple Africa’s electricity demand by 2050. Meanwhile, hydropower generation has become less certain because of climate change-related droughts.
Putting solar panels on hydropower reservoirs has gained increasing attention in the past few years and has a lot of potential advantages. Floating solar panels may generate electricity more efficiently than land-based panels because the water helps cool them to an optimum operating temperature, and the electricity they generate can be fed right into the grid via the hydropower dam’s existing infrastructure.
“Floating photovoltaics (FPV) is fast becoming cost-competitive, but its social and environmental impacts are under debate,” researchers write in a paper published in Nature Energy. “Meanwhile, developing economies anticipate hundreds of new dams over the next decade, with social and environmental implications for the next century.”
In the new study, researchers used a comprehensive model of the energy system across the entire African continent to explore the tradeoffs among energy production, agriculture, environmental protection, and economic development involved with floating solar.
FPV power production potential varies from one region of Africa to another. But if floating solar panels were deployed as widely as possible across the continent, they could produce between 20 and 100% of the electricity expected from hydropower dams currently slated for construction in Africa, the researchers report.
Floating solar could supply 6-7% of the continent’s total projected energy demand in 2050. The most cost-effective way to incorporate floating solar in Africa’s energy system depends on the panels’ efficiency and their cost.
The researchers also conducted a case study of FPV and hydropower potential in the Zambezi watercourse, a river system that traverses eight countries in southern Africa. This analysis showed that it would be more efficient to take the money earmarked for new dams in the river system and use it to build floating solar instead.
This approach would result in an electricity generation system with 12% less variability from year to year compared to a hydropower-heavy approach. “Adopting FPV in place of intensive hydropower development results in a more predictable output over longer timescales, which could lead to greater electricity reliability and lower reliance on imports in times of drought,” the researchers write. In other words, floating solar is a strategy for climate change resilience.
Floating solar does have drawbacks, such as disrupting existing uses like fishing and recreation on reservoirs. But new hydropower dams have much bigger environmental and social impacts, the researchers point out, and are prone to cost overruns as well.
Source: . et al. “Floating photovoltaics may reduce the risk of hydro-dominated energy development in Africa.” Nature Energy 2024.
Floating photovoltaics may reduce the risk of hydro-dominated energy development in Africa
Nature Energy volume 9, pages 602–611 (2024)
Abstract
Floating photovoltaics (FPV) is fast becoming cost-competitive, but its social and environmental impacts are under debate. Meanwhile, developing economies anticipate hundreds of new dams over the next decade, with social and environmental implications for the next century. In this context, we estimate that FPV could produce 20–100% of the electricity expected from Africa’s planned hydropower depending on the scale of FPV deployment and its cost and efficiency relative to land-based photovoltaics. Here, at the system scale, we show that the same capital investment earmarked for planned dams in the Zambezi watercourse could be used more efficiently by building fewer reservoirs and substituting the energy supply with FPV. This approach yields an energy output 12% less variable and more robust to long-term hydrological changes. Our findings suggest that FPV’s potential to avoid the environmental, social and financial risks of hydro-dominated energy development may outweigh its potential impacts on existing reservoir uses.
References
-
Moran, E. F., Lopez, M. C., Moore, N., Müller, N. & Hyndman, D. W. Sustainable hydropower in the 21st century. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 115, 11891–11898 (2018).
-
Zarfl, C., Lumsdon, A. E., Berlekamp, J., Tydecks, L. & Tockner, K. A global boom in hydropower dam construction. Aquat. Sci. 77, 161–170 (2015).
-
Hydropower Special Market Report (International Energy Agency, 2021).
-
Xu, R. et al. A global-scale framework for hydropower development incorporating strict environmental constraints. Nat. Water 1, 113–122 (2023).
-
Hydroelectricity—Analysis and Key Findings (International Energy Agency, 2022).
-
Karanfil, F. & Li, Y. Electricity consumption and economic growth: exploring panel-specific differences. Energy Policy 82, 264–277 (2015).
-
Almeida Prado, F. et al. How much is enough? An integrated examination of energy security, economic growth and climate change related to hydropower expansion in Brazil. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 53, 1132–1136 (2016).
-
Aweke, A. T. & Navrud, S. Valuing energy poverty costs: household welfare loss from electricity blackouts in developing countries. Energy Econ. 109, 105943 (2022).
-
Yalew, S. G. et al. Impacts of climate change on energy systems in global and regional scenarios. Nat. Energy 5, 794–802 (2020).
-
Spalding-Fecher, R., Joyce, B. & Winkler, H. Climate change and hydropower in the Southern African Power Pool and Zambezi River Basin: system-wide impacts and policy implications. Energy Policy 103, 84–97 (2017).
-
van Vliet, M. T. H., Wiberg, D., Leduc, S. & Riahi, K. Power-generation system vulnerability and adaptation to changes in climate and water resources. Nat. Clim. Chang. 6, 375–380 (2016).
-
Conway, D., Dalin, C., Landman, W. A. & Osborn, T. J. Hydropower plans in eastern and southern africa increase risk of concurrent climate-related electricity supply disruption. Nat. Energy 2, 946–953 (2017).
-
Foster, B. T., Kern, J. D. & Characklis, G. W. Mitigating hydrologic financial risk in hydropower generation using index-based financial instruments. Water Resour. Econ. 10, 45–67 (2015).
-
Hamilton, A. L., Characklis, G. W. & Reed, P. M. Managing financial risk trade-offs for hydropower generation using snowpack-based index contracts. Water Resour. Res. 56, e2020WR027212 (2020).
-
Almeida, R. M. et al. Climate change may impair electricity generation and economic viability of future Amazon hydropower. Glob. Environ. Change 71, 102383 (2021).
-
Global Renewables Outlook: Energy Transformation 2050 (International Renewable Energy Agency, 2020).
-
Zhang, Y. et al. Long-term basin-scale hydropower expansion under alternative scenarios in a global multisector model. Environ. Res. Lett. 17, 114029 (2022).
-
Carlino, A. et al. Declining cost of renewables and climate change curb the need for African hydropower expansion. Science 381, eadf5848 (2023).
-
Jin, Y. et al. Energy production and water savings from floating solar photovoltaics on global reservoirs. Nat. Sustain. 6, 865–874 (2023).
-
Almeida, R. M. et al. Floating solar power could help fight climate change—let’s get it right. Nature 606, 246–248 (2022).
-
Kougias, I., Szabó, S., Monforti-Ferrario, F., Huld, T. & Bódis, K. A methodology for optimization of the complementarity between small-hydropower plants and solar PV systems. Renew. Energy 87, 1023–1030 (2016).
-
Ming, B. et al. Optimizing utility-scale photovoltaic power generation for integration into a hydropower reservoir by incorporating long- and short-term operational decisions. Appl. Energy 204, 432–445 (2017).
-
Fang, W. et al. Optimal sizing of utility-scale photovoltaic power generation complementarily operating with hydropower: a case study of the world’s largest hydro-photovoltaic plant. Energy Convers. Manag. 136, 161–172 (2017).
-
Lee, N. et al. Hybrid floating solar photovoltaics-hydropower systems: benefits and global assessment of technical potential. Renew. Energy 162, 1415–1427 (2020).
-
World Population Prospects 2022: Summary of Results (United Nations, 2023).
-
Puig, D. et al. An action agenda for Africa’s electricity sector. Science 373, 616–619 (2021).
-
Africa Energy Outlook (International Energy Agency, 2022).
-
Schmitt, R. J. P., Kittner, N., Kondolf, G. M. & Kammen, D. M. Joint strategic energy and river basin planning to reduce dam impacts on rivers in myanmar. Environ. Res. Lett. 16, 054054 (2021).
-
Siala, K., Chowdhury, A. K., Dang, T. D. & Galelli, S. Solar energy and regional coordination as a feasible alternative to large hydropower in southeast asia. Nat. Commun. 12, 4159 (2021).
-
Sterl, S. et al. Smart renewable electricity portfolios in west africa. Nat. Sustain. 3, 710–719 (2020).
-
Wu, G. C. et al. Strategic siting and regional grid interconnections key to low-carbon futures in african countries. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 114, E3004–E3012 (2017).
-
Chowdhury, A. F. M. K. et al. Enabling a low-carbon electricity system for Southern Africa. Joule 6, 1826–1844 (2022).
-
Winemiller, K. O. et al. Balancing hydropower and biodiversity in the Amazon, Congo, and Mekong. Science 351, 128–129 (2016).
-
Schmitt, R. J. P., Bizzi, S., Castelletti, A., Opperman, J. J. & Kondolf, G. M. Planning dam portfolios for low sediment trapping shows limits for sustainable hydropower in the mekong. Sci. Adv. 5, eaaw2175 (2019).
-
Bertoni, F., Castelletti, A., Giuliani, M. & Reed, P. M. Discovering dependencies, trade-offs, and robustness in joint dam design and operation: an ex-post assessment of the Kariba Dam. Earths Future 7, 1367–1390 (2019).
-
Giuliani, M., Lamontagne, J. R., Hejazi, M. I., Reed, P. M. & Castelletti, A. Unintended consequences of climate change mitigation for African River Basins. Nat. Clim. Chang.12, 187–192 (2022).
-
Opperman, J. J. et al. Balancing renewable energy and river resources by moving from individual assessments of hydropower projects to energy system planning. Front. Environ. Sci. Eng. China 10, 1036653 (2023).
-
Almeida, R. M. et al. Strategic planning of hydropower development: balancing benefits and socioenvironmental costs. Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 56, 101175 (2022).
-
Chowdhury, A. F. M. K., Kern, J., Dang, T. D. & Galelli, S. PowNet: a network-constrained unit commitment/economic dispatch model for large-scale power systems analysis. J. Open Res. Softw. 8, 5 (2020).
-
Hauer, C., Siviglia, A. & Zolezzi, G. Hydropeaking in regulated rivers—from process understanding to design of mitigation measures. Sci. Total Environ. 579, 22–26 (2017).
-
Liu, X. & Xu, Q. Hydropeaking impacts on riverine plants downstream from the world’s largest hydropower dam, the three gorges dam. Sci. Total Environ. 845, 157137 (2022).
-
Gonzalez, J. M. et al. Designing diversified renewable energy systems to balance multisector performance. Nat. Sustain. 6, 415–427 (2023).
-
Matheu, E. E., Yezierski, M. E., Rtzer, K. S. & Freer, C. Security considerations for protecting dams and levees. J. Dam Saf. 19, 40–48 (2022).
-
Liu, H., Krishna, V., Lun Leung, J., Reindl, T. & Zhao, L. Field experience and performance analysis of floating PV technologies in the tropics. Prog. Photovolt. Res. Appl. 26, 957–967 (2018).
-
Sen, A., Mohankar, A. S., Khamaj, A. & Karmakar, S. Emerging OSH issues in installation and maintenance of floating solar photovoltaic projects and their link with sustainable development goals. Risk Manag. Healthc. Policy 14, 1939–1957 (2021).
-
Cousse, J. Still in love with solar energy? Installation size, affect, and the social acceptance of renewable energy technologies. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 145, 111107 (2021).
-
Kohsaka, R. & Kohyama, S. Contested renewable energy sites due to landscape and socio-ecological barriers: comparison of wind and solar power installation cases in Japan. Energy Environ. 34, 2619–2641 (2023).
-
Blumstein, S. & Kramer, A. Deliverable 6.1: Common Approach and Methodological Roadmap for the Nexus Dialogues at Local and Basin level (Adelphi Consult, 2022).
-
Pappis, I. et al. Energy Projections for African Countries (European Commission Joint Research Centre, 2019).
-
Taliotis, C. et al. An indicative analysis of investment opportunities in the African electricity supply sector—using TEMBA (the electricity model base for Africa). Energy Sustain. Dev. 31, 50–66 (2016).
-
Frieler, K. et al. Assessing the impacts of 1.5 °C global warming—simulation protocol of the Inter-Sectoral Impact Model Intercomparison Project (ISIMIP2b). Geosci. Model Dev.10, 4321–4345 (2017).
-
Sterl, S. et al. A spatiotemporal atlas of hydropower in Africa for energy modelling purposes. Open Res. Eur. 1, 29 (2021).
-
Where Sun Meets Water: Floating Solar Market Report (World Bank, 2019).
-
Lee, Y.-G., Joo, H.-J. & Yoon, S.-J. Design and installation of floating type photovoltaic energy generation system using FRP members. Sol. Energy 108, 13–27 (2014).
-
Oliveira-Pinto, S. & Stokkermans, J. Assessment of the potential of different floating solar technologies—overview and analysis of different case studies. Energy Convers. Manag.211, 112747 (2020).
-
Dörenkämper, M. et al. The cooling effect of floating PV in two different climate zones: a comparison of field test data from the netherlands and singapore. Sol. Energy 219, 15–23 (2021).
-
Arnold, W., Salazar, J. Z., Carlino, A., Giuliani, M. & Castelletti, A. Operations eclipse sequencing in multipurpose dam planning. Earths Future 11, e2022EF003186 (2023).
-
PVGIS 5.2 (2022). EU Science Hub. European Commission Joint Research Centrehttps://re.jrc.ec.europa.eu/pvg_tools/en/ (2023).
-
Giuliani, M., Castelletti, A., Pianosi, F., Mason, E. & Reed, P. M. Curses, tradeoffs, and scalable management: advancing evolutionary multiobjective direct policy search to improve water reservoir operations. J. Water Resour. Plan. Manag. 142, 04015050 (2016).
-
Data and code in support of ‘Floating PV reduces risks of hydro-dominated energy development in Africa’. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10576226 (2024).
-
CORDEX Africa. Climate System Analysis Group http://www.csag.uct.ac.za/cordex-africa/(2013).
-
Data in support of ‘Declining cost of renewables and climate change curb the need for African hydropower expansion’. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7931050(2023).
-
First release of ZambeziWatercourse_GCAM code. Zenodohttps://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5726941 (2021).
-
ZRB-PowNet. GitHub https://github.com/EILab-Polimi/ZRB-PowNet (2024).
“We MUST respect this earth - it is all we have
Claudio Dametto - South Australia
“I will always Vote to Preserve Our World.
Liam McGregor - Western Australia
“A simple message that even a politician can understand
Felicity Crombach - Victoria
“Please show you care about our future generations!!
Phil Harmer - New South Wales
“Save our world , Life & health before profits.
Kerry Lillian - New South Wales
“Close down all coal mines and Do not mine gas . Make these Companies
Daniel Johnson - New South Wales
“We want carbon free energy!
Edan Clarke - New South Wales
“Feels good to be taking a voter action step
Beaver Hudson - New South Wales
“Great Initiative. Let’s Hold elected officials Accountable to their bosses, us!
John Paul Posada - New South Wales
“We need actions not words we need honest democratic govt We need a pm
Bob Pearce - South Australia
“Thank you for this great resource. I was feeling helpless. Even this small step
Silvia Anderson - Victoria
“If political parties continue receiving political donations, we will rarely have politicians working for
Dan Chicos - New South Wales
“I only vote for people who will take urgent action to restore a safe
Susie Burke - Victoria
“Current government is not representing the opinion of the majority of Australian to meet
Neil Price - Tasmania
“We are fighting to rescue our kids' future from those who seek to steal
Vanessa Norimi - Queensland
“No time to waste Now or Never My vote is for NOW
Rosalie White - Victoria
“I am only 9 but I already care
Ava Bell - New South Wales
“From New Lambton Uniting Church - Caring for our world is a moral imperative.
Niall McKay - New South Wales
“Our federal govt is an International climate Embarrassment - its about time they stepped
Oriana Tolo - Victoria
“Vote earth this time!
Sue Cooke - Queensland
“We are in one on the wealthiest countries in the world. we have the
rowan huxtable - New South Wales
“The climate Emergency is the public health opportunity and urgent priority of the 21st
Mike Forrester - Victoria
“If they want my vote they better act now
Barbara McNiff - New South Wales
“We need to act locally now for the earth. Our only home. Vote Earth
Anne Miller - New South Wales
“I often look at the places I've known all my life and see how
Jim Baird - New South Wales
“Strike one For people power!!! Democracy might prevail outside the current cronyism that faces
Lorraine Bridger - New South Wales
“Our federal politicians Are Afraid to make action on climate change a major election
Jennifer Martin - New South Wales
“climate election, let's go!
Fahimah Badrulhisham - New South Wales
“Great to see this website that is a focus on action for climate change
Lynette Sinclair - New South Wales
“Let’s show politicians and the Murdoch media that climate change is by far the
Jane Aitken - Australian Capital Territory
“If you want to stay in power You need to take action to stop
Jane Bulter - New South Wales
“We are all that stands between terminal climate change and the vulnerable. We are
Carol Khan - Queensland
“We need a Government that Believes this is real and not taking money from
Ken Gray - New South Wales
“I'm voting for my childrens future
Anneliese Alexander - New South Wales